The Bachelor 2016's Becca Tilley and Amber James vie for Ben Higgins' heart

Becca Tilley, 26, and Amber James, 30, added a wrinkle to The Bachelor premiere on Monday when they returned to the show.

Amber James's Instagram, Twitter & Facebook on IDCrawl

Amber James, Becca Tilley Returning for Ben Higgins' The Bachelor

The Bachelor season 20 The season of the crazies

The Bachelor 2016 season premiere kicks off with Ben Higgins

The Bachelor' star Ben Higgins: 'Dancing with the Stars' isn't best for my relationship with Lauren Bushnell right now

The Bachelor 2016's Becca Tilley and Amber James vie for Ben Higgins' heart

The Bachelor Ben Higgins axes one of the blonde Ferguson twins Haley

The Bachelor (Season 20), Bachelor Nation Wiki

The Bachelor OK! Magazine

Bachelor' couple Jade Roper, Tanner Tolbert announce TV wedding

The Bachelor': Twitter has a field day

Hayley Kiyoko & 'Bachelor' Star Becca Tilley Confirm Relationship

Becca Tilley arrives for iHeartRadio's KIIS FM Wango Tango By AT&T at Banc of California Stadium on, Stock Photo, Picture And Rights Managed Image. Pic. TAC-166389

Becca Tilley at AMAs. I'm sure to support Hayley Kiyoko : r

Becca Tilley Discusses Why She Keeps Her Current Relationship

Becca Tilley arrives for iHeartRadio's KIIS FM Wango Tango By AT&T